外獨會意見庫存

國際學者聯署聲明,關切台灣司法不公


發言人:歸也轉貼, on 05/11/2008  08:38:07 (IP code: 240.218)

二十位國際學者與友人聯署發表聲明,憂心台灣司法不公


二十位國際學者與關心台灣的國際友人於今日發表聯署聲明,就近日一連串台灣政府不符合司法程序,收押與起訴民進黨政府官員的舉動,表示高度關心與憂心。這份共同聲明也於今日寄送司法院院長賴英照與法務部部長王清峰。



這是國民黨政府一系列大動作收押民進黨政府官員以來,國際學者首度發表公開聲明,呼籲台灣司法維持中立,勿受政治影響,以確保台灣民主與人權。





November 4, 2008



JOINT STATEMENT

US , European and Australian scholars and writers express concern about prosecutions in Taiwan

The undersigned, scholars and writers from the US , Europe and Australia wish to express their deep concern about the recent series of detentions in Taiwan of present and former DPP government officials. To date there have been at least seven such cases (See list below).

以下聯署的國際學者對於近日台灣政府一連串拘留卸任與現任民進黨政府官員的行動,深表憂慮。直至今日,據我們瞭解共有七件類似案件。


It is obvious that there have been cases of corruption in Taiwan , but these have occurred in both political camps. The political neutrality of the judicial system is an essential element in a democracy. It is also essential that any accused are considered innocent until proven guilty in the court of law.

很明顯的,貪污這個問題在台灣依然存在,但是這樣的案例在兩大政黨裡均曾發生。司法系統維持政治中立是民主的基本要素。堅持任何被指控者在裁定有罪前均是無罪的法律理念也是必要的。


We also believe that the procedures followed by the prosecutor\'s offices are severely flawed: while one or two of the accused have been formally charged, the majority is being held incommunicado without being charged. This is a severe contravention of the writ of habeas corpus and a basic violation of due process, justice and the rule of law.

我們認為檢察官所採取的法律程序有著嚴重的缺失:雖然當一、兩位被指控者已被正式起訴時,大多數被指控者卻在未被正式起訴情況之下就遭到收押禁見。這嚴重違反了人身保護令以及正當法律程序、公義與法治。


In the meantime, the prosecutor\'s offices evidently leak detrimental information to the press. This kind of "trial by press" is a violation of the basic standards of judicial procedures. It also gives the distinct impression that the Kuomintang authorities are using the judicial system to get even with members of the former DPP government. In addition, the people who are being held incommunicado are of course unable to defend themselves against the misreporting and the leaks in the news media.

在此同時,檢察官辦公室很明顯地將相關不利消息透露給媒體。這種「透過媒體辦案」的方式違反司法程序的基本標準;也讓外界認為國民黨政府利用司法系統來報復已下台的民進黨政府。此外,被收押禁見的人,在與外界斷絕聯繫的情況下,無法澄清外界不實報導與媒體洩密。



We do firmly believe that any alleged wrongdoings must be dealt with in a fair and open manner in an impartial court. Justice through the rule of law is essential to Taiwan \'s efforts to consolidate democracy and protect fundamental human rights.

我們深信任何宣稱的犯罪行為應該以公正與公開的方式,在中立的法庭裡審判。透過法治落實司法,才能強化台灣民主與保障基本人權。


We do not want to see Taiwan \'s hard-earned democracy jeopardized in this manner. Taiwan can justifiably be proud of its transition to democracy in the late 1980s and early 1990s. It would be sad for Taiwan and detrimental to its international image if the progress which was made during the past 20 years would be erased. Taiwan needs to move forward, not backwards to the unfair and unjust procedures as practiced during the dark days of Martial Law (1947-87).

我們不願見到台灣辛苦得來的民主陷入如此困境。台灣因為在八零年代後期與九零年早期成功\轉型為民主國家,而引以為傲。如果過去二十年來的民主進展從此抺煞,這不僅將令人難過,台灣的國際形象也將受到嚴害傷害。台灣必須向前邁進,而不應是開倒車回到過去戒嚴黑暗時代的不公與不義。



Signed:

簽署人:


Nat Bellocchi, former Chairman of the American Institute in Taiwan  

Julian Baum, former Taiwan Bureau Chief, Far Eastern Economic Review

Coen Blaauw, Formosan Association for Public Affairs, Washington DC

David Prager Branner, Director at Large ( East Asia ), American Oriental Society

Gordon G. Chang, author, "The Coming Collapse of China."

June Teufel Dreyer, Professor of Political Science, University of Miami , Florida

Edward Friedman, Professor of Political Science and East Asian Studies, University of Wisconsin , Madison

Bruce Jacobs, Professor of Asian Languages and Studies, Monash University , Melbourne , Australia

Richard C. Kagan, Professor Emeritus of History, Hamline University , St. Paul Minnesota

Jerome F. Keating, Associate Professor, National Taipei University (Ret.). Author, "Island in the Stream, a quick case study of Taiwan \'s complex history" and other works on Taiwan

Daniel Lynch, Associate Professor, School of International Relations , University of Southern California

Victor H. Mair, Professor of Chinese Language and Literature, University of Pennsylvania

Donald Rodgers, Associate Professor of Political Science, Austin College , Texas

Terence Russell, Professor of Chinese Language and Literature, University of Manitoba

Scott Simon, Professor of Sociology and Anthropology, University of Ottawa

John J. Tkacik Jr., Senior Research Fellow, The Heritage Foundation, Washington DC

Gerrit van der Wees, Editor Taiwan Communiqué, Washington DC



Vincent Wei-cheng Wang, Professor of Political Science, University of Richmond , Virginia

Arthur Waldron, Lauder Professor of International Relations, University of Pennsylvania

Stephen Yates, President of DC Asia Advisory and former Deputy Assistant to the Vice President for National Security Affairs

------------ --------- --------- --------- --------- --------- ------



Specific cases of concern:



-- The arrest and detention on October 15th of former Interior minister Yu Cheng-hsien;

-- The arrest and detention on October 27th of former Hsinchu Science Park Director and Deputy Minister of Environmental Protection Dr. James Lee;

-- The arrest and detention on October 29th of DPP Chiayi County Commissioner Chen Ming-wen;

-- The indictment on October 30th of DPP Tainan City Councilor Wang Ting-yu;

-- The arrest and detention on October 31st of former National Security Council (NSC) secretary-general and Deputy Prime Minister Chiou I-jen;

-- The questioning of former Foreign Minister Dr. Mark Chen on November 3rd and insinuations in the press that he might be charged and arrested.

-- The arrest and detention on November 4th of DPP Yunlin County Magistrate Ms. Su Chih-fen.

Record ID: 1225845487 From: 美國
回信發言人:歸也, on 05/11/2008  08:42:15 (IP code: 240.218)

這些聯署學者來自美國,加拿大,澳洲,歐盟等世界各地.

Record ID: 1225845487R001 From: 美國
回信發言人:GS, on 05/11/2008  08:49:28 (IP code: 241.95)

Nat Bellocchi, former Chairman of the American Institute in Taiwan  
...................................................
前美國在台協會主席白樂崎?
美國政府已正視此問題。

Record ID: 1225845487R002 From: 台灣
回信發言人:歸也, on 05/11/2008  08:51:46 (IP code: 240.218)

馬無能利用司法打壓台灣的民主及人權,引起國際學者的關心~~

Record ID: 1225845487R003 From: 美國
回信發言人:袂凍了解, on 05/11/2008  08:54:38 (IP code: 52.157)

應該跟馬無能無關,這是中央的指令
警察搶國旗也是一樣,我相信馬無能真的沒下令
是中央下的命令,區區一個區長能怎樣?

Record ID: 1225845487R004 From: 台灣
回信發言人:K DPP & KMT, on 05/11/2008  08:55:30 (IP code: 238.131)

回信發言人:歸也, on Nov 05/2008 08:51:46 (IP code: X.X.240.218)

--------------------------------
馬無能利用司法打壓台灣的民主及人權,引起國際學者的關心~~
===================

No, 間諜扁已開始利用司法打壓台灣的民主及人權


Record ID: 1225845487R005 From: 台灣
回信發言人:歸也, on 05/11/2008  08:57:41 (IP code: 240.218)

馬無能有可能是中國共產黨員,也就是共匪,接受及執行上級的命令~~

Record ID: 1225845487R006 From: 美國
回信發言人:K DPP & KMT, on 05/11/2008  09:02:47 (IP code: 238.131)

回信發言人:歸也,

間諜扁一定是國民黨黨員,也就是混蛋,接受及執行上級的命令

Record ID: 1225845487R007 From: 台灣
回信發言人:歸也, on 05/11/2008  09:07:43 (IP code: 240.218)

以馬無能叫警察打傷台灣人民的情況推敲,很明顯可能他就是匪諜~~

檢舉匪諜破案獎金3000萬,中國國民黨訂的~~

Record ID: 1225845487R008 From: 美國
回信發言人:歸也, on 05/11/2008  09:24:22 (IP code: 240.218)

年輕時的白色恐怖夢魘又在馬無能手上死灰復燃~~

Record ID: 1225845487R009 From: 美國
回信發言人:K DPP & KMT, on 05/11/2008  09:28:06 (IP code: 238.131)

回信發言人:歸也, on Nov 05/2008 09:24:22 (IP code: X.X.240.218)

--------------------------------------
年輕時的白色恐怖夢魘又在馬無能手上死灰復燃~~
===================

No, 傳說中的白色恐怖夢魘在間諜扁手上死灰復燃
(貪污扁17歲參加國民黨, 18歲參加救國團, 19歲國民黨在他內心深處留下一顆眼淚,名字叫「思念」。從此此心不渝、此情不變,愛護國民黨直到永遠,既使當總統依然效法國民黨貪污精神,甚至比國民黨更國民黨。)

1. 花蓮地檢署的李子春叫去罰站,向李子春敬禮,還自認尊重司法的得意勁模樣了嗎?(承認不符程序的公文,法律系怎麼讀的?)
2. 正己專案對民進黨是正面,且對台灣社會有利,民進黨當時大張旗鼓宣傳,且公開聲明要開鍘42司法官,應該是合理數據,後來本案不了了之?
3. 彰檢強逼婦孺認罪,襲胸10秒無罪,南迴搞軌,雄檢以被告驗傷單為原告驗傷單,嘉義地院法庭錄音短缺15分鐘…。帳記在民進黨頭上
4. 楊朝詳、羅福助無罪,興票案不起訴、馬筒無罪,搜索鎮南宮洩密?王又曾、曾正仁、伍澤元…落跑


但可記得民進黨執政高喊尊重司法???尤其貪污扁、污雲定南喊的最假。

可憐的是民進黨的支持者,

Record ID: 1225845487R010 From: 台灣
回信發言人:歸也, on 05/11/2008  09:52:21 (IP code: 240.218)

我們來溫故知新一下

在蔣臭頭父子極權時代,由警總(包括保安司令)以軍法處理的政治案件中,約有三萬到六萬件之多,受難人多大達十四萬到二十萬之譜.白色恐怖所造成的傷害及影響,在馬無能的死灰復燃中又恢復記憶~~

Record ID: 1225845487R011 From: 美國
回信發言人:K DPP & KMT, on 05/11/2008  10:34:46 (IP code: 238.131)

我們來探討未來一下

在貪污扁當間諜時代以後, 由馬無能接連, 法務部(包括法院)以離譜處理的司法政治案件中,約有六萬件以上,受難人多大達四十萬之譜.貪污扁間諜恐怖所造成的傷害及影響,在馬無能接連下又恢復~~

Record ID: 1225845487R012 From: 台灣
回信發言人:歸也, on 05/11/2008  11:41:16 (IP code: 240.218)

蔣臭頭極權初期,逐漸實施警特高壓統治,台灣原本有良好的法治基礎的社會治安漸漸出現混亂,台灣警備總司令部變指揮特警展開爛捕亂關,監獄很快的人滿為患~~

現在馬無能叫國安指揮警特展開無故爛捕亂關台灣人民~~Sounds familiar?

Record ID: 1225845487R013 From: 美國
回信發言人:RatHunter, on 05/11/2008  12:30:23 (IP code: 197.105)

K DPP & KMT

你有完沒完啊? 乖乖靜靜的看, 沒人當你是白痴, OK?

Record ID: 1225845487R014 From: 紐西蘭
回信發言人:K DPP & KMT, on 05/11/2008  13:11:19 (IP code: 238.131)

回信發言人:RatHunter,

R U crying ?

溫故知新 => 在於探討未來 understand?

蔣臭頭死掉了 => 但蔣臭頭的抓爬精神永存台灣 => 貪污間諜扁實踐之 => 但 why ? 因為你們這些阿呆支持 => 貪污間諜扁早有跡象了 => ex. 還記得貪污扁被花蓮地檢署李子春叫去罰站,向李子春敬禮,還自認尊重司法的得意勁模樣了嗎?還搭空軍一號, 去讓一個起訴書都寫不好的檢察官罰站?

Record ID: 1225845487R015 From: 台灣
回信發言人:K DPP & KMT, on 05/11/2008  13:29:04 (IP code: 238.131)

貪污間諜扁亂權初期,逐漸實施司法離譜統治(*1) ,台灣原本有良好的法治基礎的社會治安漸漸出現混亂,台灣檢察官指揮警調展開爛捕亂關,監獄很快的人滿為患~~ 又搞大赦 ??? 擾亂治安, 終於民進黨下野

現在馬無能承繼貪污間諜扁叫國安指揮警特展開無故爛捕亂關台灣人民~~Sounds familiar?

*1 : 「南迴鐵路搞軌案」害死兩個人,但司法?一開始屏東地檢署辦案,但又轉高雄地檢署辦案?這是違反常理,因為地緣關係,屏東地檢署辦理,比較有效率。而且高雄地檢署又找個專辦「家事」案件檢察官辦案?這也是違反常理。另外主任檢察官搞不清楚「法院管轄權」…,這個貪污間諜扁政府擺明有問題

Record ID: 1225845487R016 From: 台灣
回信發言人:so, on 05/11/2008  13:58:30 (IP code: 133.228)

難怪日本會修改教科書,說從沒有南京大屠殺這回事,都是中國人捏造串演的~~

因為跟中國人爭真相,太煩的關係吧!!! (不過日本還是很殘,毫不囉唆~~)

Record ID: 1225845487R017 From: 台灣
回信發言人:cc, on 05/11/2008  15:37:04 (IP code: 194.110)

台灣法律界的腐敗,及檢察、警察高層均公開或暗中投靠中華人民共和國;無論藍、綠律師都是禁若寒蟬,不敢伸張公義、檢調單位猶如大內總管,聲押異如探農取物,台灣國將不國矣。

Record ID: 1225845487R018 From: 中國
回信發言人:K DPP & KMT, on 05/11/2008  16:04:18 (IP code: 238.131)

回信發言人:cc,

No, 台灣法律界,檢察、警察高層均早已公開投靠中華人民共和國

綠律師都是禁若寒蟬,不敢伸張公義、=> 自貪污間諜扁執政已不敢伸張公義

Record ID: 1225845487R019 From: 台灣
本篇到此告一段落———版主    2008-11-08 16:07:20

WE ARE 49ER TAIWANESE